Monday, 18 May 2015

All's Well That Ends Well by William Shakespeare (1604)

All's Well That Ends Well was based on a story from the Decameron (a collection of tales written in the 14th Century) and is often described as a problem play. It appears to be a comedy - it contains humorous scenes such as the interrogation of Parolles, and love wins out in the end - but there are other aspects of the play which are unlike Shakespeare's other comedies.
The story takes place in Rossilion, Paris, Florence and Marseilles.

 Helena & the Countess, Folger Shakespeare

The Main Players

Rosillion
Countess of Rossilion (or Rousillon)
Bertram - her son, the Count of Rossilion after his father's death Helena - a gentlewoman of the household
Lavatch - the Countess's clown
Parolles - a friend of Bertram's

Paris
King of France
Lafew (or Lafeu) - a old Lord
First & Second Lord Dumaine - Lords in the King's service  

Florence
Widow Capilet
Diana - her daughter

The Storyline

The King of France is ill and no one can cure him. When his friend Count Rossilion dies, he commands Bertram, the Count's son, to attend him at court.
Bertram takes leave of his mother and goes to the King in Paris.
As the King reminisces about Bertram's father, he laments that the skilful physician, Gerard de Narbon, is also dead and cannot help him.
Helena, the physician's daughter has been living under the care of the Countess Rossilion and secretly loves Bertram. When Bertram goes to Paris, Helena follows him and by using knowledge learnt from her father, she cures the King.
The King rewards her by allowing her to choose a husband from among the bachelors at his court and she chooses Bertram.
Bertram declares he cannot marry Helena because she is of an inferior class, but after threats from the King, he goes ahead with the marriage. Unwilling to consummate the marriage, he tells Helena to go to his mother under some pretence and he immediately runs away to the wars in Italy with his friend Parolles.
Bertram writes to Helena from Florence and says:

When thou canst get the ring upon my finger, which never shall come off, and show me a child begotten of thy body that I am father to, then call me husband; but in such a "then" I write a "never."

The Countess is furious with her son's behaviour and blames Parolles' influence. Helena goes on a pilgrimage to Florence and there she meets the Widow Capilet and her daughter Diana, who is being courted by Bertram. When Helena reveals her situation to the Capilet's, they fall in with her plan and Bertram is told that Helena is dead. Under cover of darkness, Helena takes Diana's place and goes to meet Bertram, who has promised to marry Diana. He gives Helena his ring, believing her to be Diana, and in return receives the ring that the King gave to Helena after she had cured him. Helena conceives a child that night and Bertram returns to his mother's house unaware that he had shared his bed with his wife and not Diana.
The King is also at Rossilion and expresses his grief over Helena's death. Bertram asks for his forgiveness saying that he did love Helena but when the King sees the ring he gave Helena, Bertram is suspected to have done her harm.
Diana arrives not long after which compounds affairs even more until Helena finally enters, tells Bertram that she has fulfilled both conditions he placed upon her and he declares that he will love her dearly, forever.

The king's a beggar, now the play is done; All is well ended, if this suit be done...

We listened to the BBC Arkangel audio as we read the play, spreading it over about 11 weeks. I read along with the Cambridge School guide and Benj read it from this website
 
Some thoughts:

Bertram - initially I was a little sympathetic towards him as he was expected to marry someone he had no wish to. His attitude and behaviour quickly put an end to that. He was self-seeking and callous; immature and easily led. His change of heart towards the end of the play seems a little strange.

Helena - a mixed bag. I thought she was rather insipid at times but she did end up displaying some strength of character. Did she really love Bertram or was she just ambitious? Why would she want to marry a man who had been so indifferent to her?

Countess Rossilion - a just, sensible woman who, although she thought Parolles was a bad influence on her son, didn't make excuses for Bertram's bad behaviour.

Parolles - was the source of some light hearted moments in the play even though he was a rogue. He learnt some humility towards the end.

Lafew - the quick witted old Lord discerned Parolles' true nature.

The King - benevolent and kind; his behaviour in the scenes towards the end of the play where the situation comes to a head is amusing.

Diana - both she & her mother were decent people and wanted to do what was right. She had a good head upon her shoulders and didn't allow herself to be taken in by Bertram's flattery.

Something that stood out to me was that apart from Bertram, all the people of rank and position in the play were honourable and well-intentioned. The Countess, for example, loved Helena and was happy for her to marry Bertram even though she was beneath him in rank.





This play is probably best left until highschool unless you use an abridged version such as Charles and Mary Lamb's Tales From Shakespeare. There are some interesting ideas & themes for discussion in this play regarding relationships and morals.


All's Well That Ends Well is my choice for A Classic Play as part of the Back to the Classics Challenge 2015.

9 comments:

  1. Shakespeare is one of our absolute favorite subjects here. We are currently finishing up A Midsummer's Night. At our house everyone has a copy and reads for various characters. One son loves Much Ado About Nothing and the other loves Henry V. My daughter loved Macbeth and Taming of the Shrew. I will need to add this one to our list. There are so many good ones.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm tossing up whether to do Macbeth or Hamlet next.

      Delete
    2. Macbeth is shorter. We did Hamlet earlier this year and it was sad. Macbeth is more tragic. I think I liked Macbeth more. I am sure that helps...not. LOL

      Delete
    3. I'll end up doing both anyhow!

      Delete
  2. We've recently started Shakespeare - The Tempest, albeit with the Charles and Mary Lamb version, but I am happy to have started. It will be quite the journey I imagine. I hope my girls end up liking it all.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The Lamb's version is a great place to start, even for an adult & I'm sure they'll enjoy it.

      Delete
  3. Oooo, fun! I've been fortunate enough to have visited Rousillon twice and love it there. I haven't read All's Well yet so I should move it up my list. I thoroughly enjoyed your review! And I love the Arkangel CD's. So far Richard II is my favourite, however I didn't like A Midsummer Night's Dream because they made the fairies Reggae fairies. Imagine! :-Z

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The play we saw recently made them hippies. I can't quite imagine Reggae fairies - did they all have dreadlocks?? We've listened to some very good Naxos audios of Shakespeare. The Tempest was one & Ian McLellan played Prospero.

      Delete
  4. Not a play I'm remotely familiar with. I like the selection you made of the quote about marriage. Thanks for sharing.

    ReplyDelete