Tuesday 9 August 2016

Top Ten Tuesday - my top ten uncomfortable reads


Top Ten Uncomfortable Reads

Crime & Punishment by Fyodor Dostoevsky - to be shown inside the mind of an emotionally detached, psychopathic, cruel character was unpleasant, especially as he remained in that state for about the first 400 pages. The  Russian names of the characters were difficult to keep in context, especially as many of them had the same initials: Rodion Romanovich Raskolnikov, Avdotya Romanovna Raskolnikov, Razumikhin, Zossimov, Zamyotov...

Killing Fields, Living Fields by Don Cormack - an exquisitely crafted true story that tears your heart apart. I put off reading this book as I didn't think I could handle it emotionally, but it was so beautifully written and compelling that I didn't regret it. Uncomfortable, yes, but although it describes a nation traumatised beyond belief, it is also an incredibly hope-filled account of the Cambodian Church, 'the church that would not die.'

...Cambodia has achieved a distinction which has so far eluded even those countries unfortunate enough to experience the full weight if terror brought to bear by even the most monstrous tyrants of our time; it is the first country to be transformed into a concentration camp in its entirety...
Quoted by the author from The Times, April 22, 1976


1984 by George Orwell - ugly and chilling is how I'd describe this book. It was quite prophetic considering that Orwell wrote it in 1949 and I think it's one of those 'must reads.' The terms Big Brother, Newspeak, Doublethink...all came from this book. An eye opening, awful, but important novel about the evils of totalitarianism that has as much to say now as it did when it was first published. It's available free online.

For the Term of His Natural Life by Marcus Clarke - a classic on convict life in Australia based on real events. Brutal.

Innocent Blood by P.D. James - I read somewhere that this was the novel that launched the author's career but I don't think it is as well written as some of her earlier books. I was intrigued by the idea of the exploration of identity - the main character, Philippa Palfrey, is adopted and she has built up a fantasy surrounding her biological family. What she discovers is nothing like what she imagined. I thought James lost the plot and went too far, especially regarding Philippa's relationship with her adoptive father. This was a shame, as it had all the ingredients for an interesting storyline without the shabby embellishments.

The Good Earth by Pearl Buck - a beautifully written story but emotionally raw. The fate of one the characters was so undeserved and too painful for me. It haunted me for weeks after I read it.


Madame Bovary by Gustave Flaubert - Madame was too stupid for words. I felt embarrassed by her selfish and indulgent behaviour but Flaubert was a poetic writer.

A Good Man is Hard to Find by Flannery O'Connor - uncomfortable, yes, but with a purpose (which I didn't always understand!)

Witch Wood by John Buchan - an unusual story about a young idealistic minister working amongst religious extremists in a narrow minded community in Scotland in the mid 1600's. The story raises disturbing questions about human nature and our capacity for self-deception. It's a book that draws you back because you don't feel you quite got it the first time.


Lord of the Flies by William Golding - when a plane carrying a group of schoolboys crashes into the lagoon of a remote island, the boys have to survive on their own with no adult supervision. At first they are exhilarated by the sense of freedom, but before long their behaviour degenerates as all order collapses. It's a disturbing exploration of human behaviour when external controls are removed, made all the more uncomfortable because you could imagine a bunch of schoolboys behaving like that if left to their own devices.



Unknown said...

If you want to revisit Cambodia try "First They Killed My Father" unbelievable book..

Joseph said...

I concur with 1984 and Madame B, but I...hmmm...yeah I get your point, I wouldn't say I ENJOY Lord of the Flies, but it is a favorite. I have C&P coming up soon, so we'll see how that goes. Nice list.

GretchenJoanna said...

(gulp) I will certainly save your list, even though I may never feel strong enough to make good use of it. I have read a few, but not recently.

Thank you!

Carol said...

Thanks for the suggestion, Sarah.

Carol said...

Yes, there are quite a few books I couldn't say I 'enjoyed' - sometimes we need to be made uncomfortable.

Carol said...

Most of the books above I read 5 or more years ago. I don't know how I'd react to them now. I'd like to read The Good Earth again - It hit a nerve & I over-reacted. A bit of time & maturity might make it easier next time around.

Aflyonmyhomeschoolwall said...

Oh! What a list! These are tough reads!!! The Good Earth left me shaking and aching. Lord of the Flies was so horrific that I won't even discuss it with my children or require them to read it. I told them that they're on their own with that one. I can't even remember 1984 or Madam Bovary! The others I haven't read, and knowing they are uncomfortable reads will not send me scurrying to the library!

But this was an interesting, thought-provoking post. Thank you!

Carol said...

Even taking into account my uncomfortable-ness, the only book on the above list I wouldn't recommend is Innocent Blood. Obviously, some are age appropriate also - tricky because there are books I consider important but I'm not always sure of the best time to give them to my kids.

Silvia said...

From your list, I have read C&P, Lord of..., and 1984. I agree with you, they are disturbing books, but I do like them. I love Lord of the Flies because of my memories reading it in high school and discussing it with peers and teacher.

Carol said...

I've really enjoyed a lot of dystopian books. They do make you think & in that way I don't mind being disturbed.